Comparison Test: Inexpensive Family Sedans
 

Introduction
Vehicle Details

25th Place

24th Place

23rd Place

22nd Place

21st Place

20th Place
19th Place
18th Place
17th Place

16th Place

15th Place

14th Place

13th Place

12th Place

11th Place

10th Place

9th Place

8th Place

7th Place

6th Place

5th Place

4th Place

3rd Place

2nd Place

1st Place

Evaluations
 

 

4th Place: Honda Accord

The Accord has been frequently considered to be the best family sedan, winning praise from auto enthusiasts, consumer-oriented publications, and midsize sedan buyers themselves. (The Toyota Camry continues to post higher sales numbers, but it tends to win less editorial acclaim.) There are good reasons for that. It posts strong safety ratings, drives quite well, has a comfortable and high-quality interior, and returns an impressive mix of capable acceleration and excellent gas mileage. But in this value-oriented section of the family sedan marketplace, low prices are key to success. And while the Accord has its excellence, its pricing suggests that Honda recognizes this fully.

 

The Accord has a very comfortable ride, well-controlled and firm, though a bit less absorbent than other class leaders. As a result, it also handles very well. It is not a sports sedan, but it has well-controlled body roll, a nimble feel, and responsive, accurate steering, making it more fun-to-drive than most competitors. The standard 2.4-liter 4-cylinder provides brisk acceleration for a 4-cylinder, better even than some 6-cylinders in this group, while still tying for the best fuel economy among the twenty-five cars here. The engine remains smooth and quiet even under acceleration, but wind noise is audible even before highway speeds.

 

Inside, the Accord’s firm, comfortable front seats are mounted high enough, and are quite roomy and well-shaped. The rear isn’t as high or as spacious as some competitors’, but it is well-shaped to make the best of that, and is still quite comfortable overall. The interior is solidly constructed from high-quality materials. The gauges are large and clear, and the large, well-placed instruments are very easy to use. Entry/exit would be easier with wider door openings, but the well-shaped roofline facilitates getting in and out. Drivers sit very comfortable, and have good visibility. The trunk is quite small, and the Accord oddly lacks a split-folding rear seat.

 

The Accord did very well in crash testing. It earned five stars for both the driver and for the front passenger in the NHTSA frontal crash test, and four stars for both the driver and for the rear passenger in the NHTSA side crash test. It was rated Best Pick in the IIHS offset crash test, and Good in the IIHS side crash test. Its head restraints were rated Poor, however.

 

The Accord reviewed here came in at $20,375. It is not particularly well-equipped at that price, coming only with its standard equipment. That does include the basic power accessories (no power seats) and such safety features as antilock brakes, torso-protecting side airbags, and curtain side airbags. Traction and stability control are only offered on the more-expensive V6 models, as are virtually every other accessory except the basics in comfort and safety.

 

Overall, the Accord is a very impressive car. But in the $20,000 price range, value is key, and it is an area at which the Accord does not excel, coming with no more than the basic accessories without a price advantage. And it is not so much better than its competitors that the significant price difference can’t be overlooked, with a less-absorbent ride and less rear-seat space than some key competitors and less trunk space than virtually all. It is an excellent family car, and is definitely worth a look from midsize sedan shoppers, but the competition has caught up and can sell most of the same benefits for a much lower price.

 

 

The Basics:

 

 Vehicle Reviewed:

 2006 Honda Accord

 LX

 2.4-liter I4 (166 hp)

 5-speed automatic

 $20,375

 

  Pros:

-Interior Comfort

-Ride Comfort

-Refinement

-Fuel Economy

-Agility

-Safety Ratings

-Interior Quality

-Ergonomics

 

 Cons:

-Features for the Money

-Trunk Space

 

Overall:

No longer the only family sedan with its many strong points, but still one of the most expensive.  

IFCAR Home

Reviews

Pricing

Other Sources

Top Picks

Vehicle Info

About IFCAR

Contact IFCAR

© 2005, Institute For Consumer Automotive Research