Comparison Test: Compact Wagons  
 

Introduction

Vehicle Details

13th Place

12th Place

11th Place

10th Place

9th Place

8th Place

7th Place

6th Place

5th Place

4th Place

3rd Place

2nd Place

1st Place
Evaluations


 

 

1st Place: Ford Focus ZXW

 

Unlike newer competitors like the Dodge Caliber and Chevrolet HHR, the Focus doesn’t try to disguise the fact that it is a station wagon. And Ford has done little to disguise the fact that the Focus has been on sale in this country with only minor changes since 2000. If the Focus had not been so well executed from the start, it would not have lasted six full model years with enough staying power to keep going into the seventh, which it has and will. And it still has an unmatched ride/handling compromise in a compact car, one of the roomiest interiors for passengers and (depending on the actual specs of the Mazda5) the roomiest for cargo. The Focus is a conventional wagon without distracting styling cues that could possibly limit its function, and it is splendidly executed. It doesn’t have the latest safety equipment, it’s not the most powerful or refined here, and its interior could use yet another upgrade, but it is an excellent vehicle in almost every way, and is one of the least expensive cars in this group. It is the unquestionable class leader.

 

The Focus ZXW has a firm, comfortable, absorbent, and very well-controlled ride. It never feels stiff, but body roll is suppressed much better than many hard-riding cars, and the car feels very nimble, almost as much as its smaller and lighter sedan and hatchback versions. The excellent steering is responsive and provides excellent feedback. The Focus is a close second behind the Mazda3 as the most fun to drive car in this class and has a more comfortable ride, and is much more fun than almost anything else in the group. The car isn’t exceptionally quick, but it never feels underpowered, and it is perfectly capable in routine driving. Recent improvements have led to better refinement; the engine isn’t particularly noisy even under hard acceleration, but there is some excess road noise on rough pavement. The Focus returns good gas mileage.

 

Inside, the Focus also continues to impress. The high, well-shaped, comfortable, and supportive front seats also offer excellent leg and head room. The rear is also impressive, with excellent cushion height and shape. There isn’t as much legroom as in some competitors, but the seat is shaped right to maximize the available space, and there is plenty of foot room beneath the front seats. Head restraints are a disappointing omission, however. Despite a recent upgrade, the Focus still doesn’t have the interior quality found in many competing models. There are too many cheap-feeling and mismatched plastics all around the car, but at least most trim pieces fit together well-enough. The gauges could be larger, but are clear, and the instruments are conveniently placed. Drivers sit very comfortably and have excellent visibility. Few drivers will need the optional telescoping steering wheel, but it’s a relatively rare and welcome feature for those who do. The cargo area is large, well-shaped, and easy to access. The rear seats do not fold as easily as in most of the others here, however.

 

The Focus wagon has not been crash tested, but the Focus sedan was rated Good in its IIHS offset crash test and Poor in its IIHS side crash test without the optional side airbags. The Focus’s head restraints were judged to be Marginal. It earned five stars for the driver and four for the front passenger in NHTSA’s frontal crash test, and three stars for the driver and four for the rear passenger in NHTSA’s side crash test without the optional side airbags.

 

The Focus ZXW reviewed here came in at $16,090, a very good price by this group’s standards, reasonably well-equipped. The Focus doesn’t offer curtain-style side airbags, but does include traction control at that price.

 

Overall, the Focus ZXW does not follow the trend of disguising a wagon for what it really is, and is much more practical than the tall hatchbacks in this group as a result. And its age has led to discounting, making it less expensive than most. It still has the endearing ride/handling compromise, seat comfort, and cargo space that it came to the market with, and combines reasonable acceleration, fuel economy, and refinement and a low price into what is easily the best all-around vehicle in this group. It doesn’t have a premium feel, exceptional gas mileage, notably quick acceleration, or a third seat. But aside from its desperate need of an interior overhaul, it does everything at least competently and inexpensively, and leads the class in many areas. Easily the best vehicle in its class.

 

NEXT PAGE

 

 

The Basics:

 

 Vehicle Reviewed:

 2006 Ford Focus ZXW

 SE

 2.0-liter V6 (136 hp)

 4-speed automatic

 $16,090

 

  Pros:

-Price

-Interior Comfort

-Ride Comfort

-Agility

-Steering Feel

-Cargo Space

-Fuel Economy

 

 Cons:

-Interior Quality

 

 Overall:

Fun, practicality, comfort, and value combine to make a car that’s going into its seventh year on the market and still going strong.          

  

IFCAR Home

Reviews

Pricing

Other Sources

Top Picks

Vehicle Info

About IFCAR

Contact IFCAR

© 2006, Institute For Consumer Automotive Research