Comparison Test: Economy Sedans  
 

Introduction

Vehicle Details

17th Place

16th Place

15th Place

14th Place

13th Place

12th Place

11th Place

10th Place

9th Place

8th Place

7th Place

6th Place

5th Place

4th Place

3rd Place

2nd Place

1st Place
Evaluations


 

 

8th Place: Toyota Yaris

  

The Yaris, like the Echo that it replaced, is a subcompact car that’s priced alongside compacts. A demand for fuel-efficiency leaves this car selling at its sticker price, which leaves it insignificantly less expensive than Toyota’s larger and nearly as fuel-efficient Corolla model. And despite its newer design and similar price to that model, the Corolla is superior in terms of interior space, comfort, and quality, acceleration and refinement, and ride and handling. For its own merits, a comfortable interior, a reasonable price, strong crash-test performance, and terrific gas mileage, the Yaris isn’t a bad car, but the Corolla is a better choice.

 

The Yaris rides comfortably, but its light weight prevents a truly settled feel on the highway or over some bumps. Handling is rather sloppy for a small car (though safe) and the steering is numb and could react faster. Its light weight lets the small engine deliver adequate performance around town, but it strains at harder high-speed acceleration. It is rather noisy under acceleration and at highway-speed cruise as well, though wind and road noise are adequately suppressed. Gas mileage leads the group, at least.

 

Inside, the Yaris offers roomy and high-mounted but small and shapeless seats in the front and rear. The interior is very basic with many hard plastics, but it is well-assembled. Visibility is good, but a telescoping steering column would make taller drivers a lot more comfortable behind the wheel. (The Corolla has received that same criticism since the 2003 model year, so Toyota cannot claim ignorance to the issue or its remedy.) The center-mounted gauges take getting used to and should be larger, and are not angled toward the driver as they are in the Saturn Ion or in the Toyota Echo the Yaris has replaced. The instruments are at least well laid out and easy  to use. Entry/exit is easy to the front and rear. The trunk is adequately roomy for a subcompact car, and it is well-shaped.

 

The Yaris reviewed here came in at $16,035, without any more than the basics. It came with the expected features in this group (except traction control) but was the only car in the group to not include anything more at the price reviewed.

 

Overall, the Yaris offers top-notch fuel economy and general adequacy elsewhere. But unless the highest possible gas mileage at sub-hybrid pricing is your most important criteria, there are better choices, including Toyota’s own Corolla. Remember not to consider a few extra miles per gallon to be a huge money saver when other cars in this group cost nearly $2,000 and still get very good gas mileage compared to anything but other economy cars.

 

NEXT PAGE

 

 

The Basics:

 

 Vehicle Reviewed:

 2007 Toyota Yaris Base

 1.5-liter I4 (106 hp)

 4-speed automatic

 $16,035

 

  Pros:

-Fuel Economy

-Interior Space

-Safety Ratings

 

 Cons:

-Agility

-Acceleration

-Driving Position

 

 Overall: 6/10

An adequate car with exceptional gas mileage.  

IFCAR Home

Reviews

Pricing

Other Sources

Top Picks

Vehicle Info

About IFCAR

Contact IFCAR

© 2007, Institute For Consumer Automotive Research