Comparison Test: Inexpensive Family Sedans  
 

Introduction

Vehicle Details

25th Place

24th Place

23rd Place

22nd Place

21st Place

20th Place

19th Place

18th Place

17th Place

16th Place

15th Place

14th Place

13th Place

12th Place

11th Place

10th Place

9th Place

8th Place

7th Place

6th Place

5th Place

4th Place

3rd Place

1st Place
Evaluations


 

 

20th Place: Pontiac G6 3.5

19th Place: Pontiac G6 2.4

  

Like the larger Pontiac Grand Prix, the G6 is a family sedan with sporty pretensions that compromise its family-sedan usability without benefit. It outscores Pontiac’s more-expensive sedan even without its price advantage thanks to more-comfortable seats, superior crash test results, and better gas mileage. However, its stiff ride and lack of real driving enjoyment, as well as relative lack of rear seat space, are distinctly similar to the Grand Prix, and both vehicles have more-practical variants that are just as fun to drive. The 4-cylinder G6 has a more comfortable ride, better gas mileage, and a lower price than the V6, at the expense of acceleration and quietness and a small benefit in steering and handling.

 

The G6 has a rather stiff, uncomfortable ride that is unsettled over uneven pavement and not absorbent. The V6 model’s “sport suspension” makes matters even worse. Despite this, neither G6 is particularly agile. It performs capably in fast cornering, but it doesn’t feel nimble or fun to drive. Body roll is at least well-contained. The 4-cylinder’s numb, overly-light, and rather vague steering further hinders the driving experience; the V6’s is a bit better. The 4-cylinder G6 has sufficient power for most situations, but the 3.5-liter V6 offers much more usable power, particularly at highway speed passing. A 3.9-liter V6 is also available on the sport-oriented GTP, above this group’s price bracket. Road noise is excessive however, and both engines can sound harsh under acceleration. The 4-cylinder offers better gas mileage than the V6.

 

Inside, the G6 has comfortable and supportive front seats, but rear is too low and hard, and though the seat is reasonably well-shaped, headroom is insufficient for taller drivers, limited by the car’s sloping roofline. The interior uses too many hard, cheap plastics on the center stack, and some trim pieces Accessing the rear around the sloping roof requires care. Drivers sit comfortably enough, and the coupe-like styling doesn’t interfere with rearward visibility as one might expect. The trunk is small by this group’s standards, and it is somewhat narrow as well.

 

The 4-cylinder G6 reviewed here came in at $18,622, and the V6 version at about $1,200 more. Both came well-equipped, including GM’s OnStar driver assistance system, power-adjustable pedals, satellite radio, a 4-way power driver’s seat, and automatic headlights. The V6 adds alloy wheels. Stability control is only offered on the top-of-the-line GXP.

 

Overall, the G6 is superior to Pontiac’s own rather similarly-designed Grand Prix, even before its lower price is a factor. And while it has the strong points of reasonable pricing, decent safety ratings, and good gas mileage, GM also sells a version of this car as the Chevrolet Malibu, which combines those strengths into a more well-rounded package that only looks any less sporty.

 

NEXT PAGE

 

 

The Basics:

 

 Vehicles Reviewed:

 2007 Pontiac G6

 Base

 2.4-liter I4 (169 hp)

 4-speed automatic

 $18,622

 

 2007 Pontiac G6

 Base

 3.5-liter I4 (224 hp)

 4-speed automatic

 $20,232

 

  Pros:

-Acceleration (3.5)

-Fuel Economy (2.4)

-Features for the money

 

 Cons:

-Rear Seat

-Interior Quality

-Ride Comfort

-Trunk Space

-Refinement

 

 Overall: 5/10

While the G6 nicer car than the Grand Prix, pseudo-sport aspects were clearly given priority over family sedan virtues here as well.

 

  

IFCAR Home

Reviews

Pricing

Other Sources

Top Picks

Vehicle Info

About IFCAR

Contact IFCAR

© 2007, Institute For Consumer Automotive Research