Comparison Test: Inexpensive Family Sedans  
 

Introduction

Vehicle Details

25th Place

24th Place

23rd Place

22nd Place

21st Place

20th Place

19th Place

18th Place

17th Place

16th Place

15th Place

14th Place

13th Place

12th Place

11th Place

10th Place

9th Place

8th Place

7th Place

6th Place

5th Place

4th Place

3rd Place

1st Place
Evaluations


 

 

25th Place: Pontiac Grand Prix

  

With the Grand Prix, Pontiac attempted to blend the virtues of a sporty coupe with those of a family sedan, and failed spectacularly. Instead of mixing the two vehicles’ strong points, it incorporated their weakest ones into the vehicle, leaving it with the poor visibility and rear seat space that results from the car’s coupelike styling, and the stiff ride that results from the firm suspension tuning. But the Grand Prix is still a rather large car, and still handles like one. The only positive sporty quality that made it into this vehicle was the reasonably powerful V6, and even that is only a standard-issue GM powertrain.

 

As noted, the Grand Prix rides very stiffly. Bumps and other road imperfections are poorly filtered, and the ride feels unsettled even at highway speeds on smooth pavement. Road and engine noise are pronounced, but wind noise is reasonably well-muted. The car's firm suspension tuning prevents excessive body roll in cornering, but the slow and unresponsive steering keeps the car from feeling sporty, and it feels its size in fast turns. The 3.8-liter V6 at least delivers prompt acceleration, the only remotely sporty aspect of the driving experience, but even that area it falls well short of many competitors. Fuel economy isn’t bad for a large sedan with a large V6, but the Grand Prix gets poor gas mileage by this group’s standards.

 

Inside, the front seats are adequately comfortable, but the poorly-contoured seat cushion feels lumpy, and a bit too firm. And the rear seat is one of the worst in this group, less-comfortable than most compact sedans'. The sporty roofline eats into the headroom, and the seat had to be mounted quite low to compensate, which, along with the short cushion and minimal leg and foot space, destroy any levels of seat comfort. The high window line further diminishes rear passenger visibility, especially for smaller occupants. The dash is coated in cheap, hard plastic trim pieces that at least fit together well. The instruments are angled towards the driver, and are generally simple to use. The gauges are quite clear and notably large. Getting in and out of the front seats is fairly easy, but the low roof and small footwell greatly complicate entry/exit to the rear. The driver sits comfortably, but the sloping windowline inhibits rearward visibility. The trunk is roomy at least, the only merit to emerge from the vehicle’s size.

 

The Grand Prix straddled this group’s price limit, coming in at $20,940, and isn’t especially well-equipped at that price. It lacks safety features like side airbags and stability control, which are only offered and higher trims of the car, but does include GM’s OnStar driver assistance system, automatic headlights, a 6-way power driver’s seat, and alloy wheels.

 

Overall, the Grand Prix is a large sedan priced among inexpensive midsize ones. Yet in favor of sporty pretensions, it eliminates all possible large sedan benefits, such as a comfortable ride and a roomy interior. It is also priced rather high to make room for the smaller (but superior) G6 to slot beneath it in the Pontiac lineup. Also consider the car’s poor safety ratings and gas mileage, and the Grand Prix’s few merits are completely insufficient to save it from ranking dead last here.

 

NEXT PAGE

 

 

The Basics:

 

 Vehicle Reviewed:

 2007 Pontiac Grand Prix

 Base

 3.8-liter V6 (200 hp)

 4-speed automatic

 $20,940

 

  Pros:

-Acceleration

-Trunk Space

 

 Cons:

-Interior Space

-Interior Quality

-Ride

-Refinement

-Fuel Economy

-Price

 

 Overall: 2/10

The downsides of a sporty car and a large family car combined to make a cramped and uncomfortable pseudo-sporty large family car.

  

IFCAR Home

Reviews

Pricing

Other Sources

Top Picks

Vehicle Info

About IFCAR

Contact IFCAR

© 2007, Institute For Consumer Automotive Research