Comparison Test: Large Sedans  
 

Introduction
Vehicle Details

15th Place

14th Place

13th Place

12th Place

11th Place

10th Place

9th Place

8th Place

7th Place

6th Place

5th Place

4th Place

3rd Place

2nd Place

1st Place
Evaluations


 

 

6th Place: Kia Amanti

 

The Amanti can be considered a modern interpretation of the Ford Crown Victoria and the Mercury Grand Marquis. Like those cars, it has a very soft ride and quite sloppy handling, though its newer platform and the increased space efficiency of its front-wheel-drive construction give it as much interior room from a much smaller exterior, and better-shaped and better-padded seats allow for much more comfort. And the interior is also of excellent quality, and has clear ergonomics. And the price is much lower. But the Amanti’s handling is at a level of queasiness unknown even to the outsized and outdated Ford Throwbacks, and fuel economy is just as poor, both consequences of a surprising weight. But for its roomy, comfortable, and high-quality interior, and for its low price, the Amanti merits consideration from more than the Crown/Marquis crowd.

 

The Amanti has very soft suspension tuning that absorbs road imperfections very well but lacks control; particularly at high speeds, a bump can set it into a rather extensive period of buoyant motions before it can regain composure. While some may actually prefer that sort of floaty ride, the corresponding handling response is much less subjective. The car feels clumsy, with pronounced body roll even in routine driving, as if the car is always asking to be driven more gently. The steering is numb and, in some situations, almost disconcertingly slow to respond. The car’s remarkably substantial weight prevents the 3.5-liter V6 from delivering rapid acceleration, but the car never sounds or feels strained. Engine, wind, and road noise are superbly suppressed for this price range. Gas mileage ties with the V8 Chrysler and Ford products at the bottom of this group.

 

Inside, the Amanti’s front seats are high, well-shaped, and supportive, though perhaps firmer than some may prefer. There is plenty of leg and head space, and the seats are wide. No front bench seat is offered. The rear is high, well-shaped, supportive, and very comfortable, and here as well head and leg space are plentiful. Feet fit comfortably under the front seats, and even middle-position occupants will be fairly comfortable. The interior is of excellent quality, the high-quality materials fit together very well. The instruments are logically placed and easy to use, and the gauges are very clear. Drivers sit comfortably despite the lack of either a telescoping steering wheel or power-adjustable pedals, and have unimpeded visibility. Wide, well-shaped door openings, large footwells, and the high roof facilitate entry/exit. The trunk isn’t very large, and while it is usefully shaped and easy to access, the rear seats cannot fold to increase capacity.

 

The Amanti was rated Good in its IIHS offset crash test, and its head restraints were Acceptable. The IIHS has not conducted its side-impact evaluation on the car, and NHTSA has no crash-tested it at all.

 

The Amanti reviewed here came in at an impressively low $27,300, very well-equipped. It has no satellite radio, but heated power leather seats with memory, traction and stability control, front-seat torso-protecting side airbags and curtain-style head-protecting side airbags for front and rear occupants, a 6-disc CD changer with cassette, and active head restraints.

 

Overall, the Amanti offers as much luxury as any other car in this class, for a price that undercuts any other contender for such a title. But the car’s sloppy ride and handling, poor fuel economy, and relative lack of power and trunk space weigh against its many merits in this group. It’s certainly worth a look for its luxury for the money, offering its comfort and refinement at mainstream family sedan prices, and excellent deals can be had on leftover 2005-model Amantis, of which many dealers still have a surplus. But it is not the well-rounded package it would need to be to score higher here.

 

 

The Basics:

 

 Vehicle Reviewed:

 2006 Kia Amanti

 3.5-liter V6 (200 hp)

 5-speed automatic

 $27,300

 

  Pros:

-Refinement

-Features for the Money

-Interior Comfort

-Interior Quality

 

 Cons:

-Agility

-Fuel Economy

-Ride Control

-Trunk Volume

 

Overall:

A value-priced luxury sedan that could stand to lose 500 lbs.

  

IFCAR Home

Reviews

Pricing

Other Sources

Top Picks

Vehicle Info

About IFCAR

Contact IFCAR

© 2005, Institute For Consumer Automotive Research