Comparison Test: Luxury Un-Sport Sedans  
 

Introduction

Vehicle Details

5th Place

4th Place

3rd Place

2nd Place

1st Place
Evaluations


 

 

3rd Place: Lexus ES350

 

Though the Toyota Camry-based ES350 is quite a bit smaller than the others here, it shares the intent of focusing entirely on comfort and luxury in a market class where most like-sized competitors seek to provide a measure of sportiness, and the rest focus primarily on that end of the spectrum. And the ES is excellent at offering comfort and luxury with a respected premium badge, and its sacrifice of some rear-seat volume lets it handle at least as well as the large sedans in this group despite its strong comfort bias. It’s much better than the less expensive Town Car, and more luxury for the money than the pricier DTS. However, the ES350 does not stand up as well against similar mainstream-branded cars, which offer more space and nearly the same refinement, comfort, and luxury.

 

The ES350 has a soft and absorbent but reasonably well-controlled ride, very comfortable overall. It isn’t as big as the others here, which helps its handling relative to the others in this group, but it is by no means agile, and while its steering is responsive, it is light and numb. The 272-horsepower V6 combines with a 6-speed automatic and a relatively light weight to move the Lexus effortlessly and nearly silently while still returning impressive gas mileage. Some may prefer the sounds of GM’s smooth V8 to this engine’s subdued hum under acceleration, however. Wind and road noise are generally inaudible.

 

Inside, the ES350 impresses with roomy and very comfortable front seats, though they could offer a bit more lateral support. The rear isn’t nearly as roomy as some of the others here, and while the seat is well-shaped, it is mounted too low. The dash features impeccable detail and high-quality materials, easily the best in this group. The gauges are very clear but could be larger, and the instruments are very easy to use. The audio controls are mostly independent from the navigation system, which is more convenient than the alternative. Drivers sit very comfortably, and have good visibility. The navigation screen is also used as a backup camera monitor. Entry/exit is easy to the front, but requires a bit more ducking under the sloping roofline to get into and out of the low rear seats. The trunk is rather small even for a midsize sedan, but aside from the intrusion of its hinges, it is well-shaped.

 

The ES350 reviewed here came in very well equipped at $39,454. At that price it includes all the features expected in this class as well as extras like a wireless cell phone link, a power adjustable tilt/telescoping steering wheel with memory, rain-sensing wipers, rear-seat torso-protecting side airbags, a rear-view backup monitor, a power rear sunshade, heated and cooled front seats, and a tire-pressure monitor.

 

Overall, the ES350 is a genuine midsize luxury car. It is comfortable, quiet, high-quality, well-equipped, and expensive. However, the large luxury sedans from the mainstream brands of Buick and Toyota are also comfortable, quiet, high-quality, and well-equipped, and offer more space and a lower price. The ES350 out-luxuries them, but they are in the ballpark. This Lexus is a reasonable choice for comfort and luxury, but make sure to check out the others before paying the price premium for this car.

 

NEXT PAGE

 

 

The Basics:

 

 Vehicle Reviewed:

 2007 Lexus ES350

 3.5-liter V6 (272 hp)

 6-speed automatic

 $39,454

 

  Pros:

-Feature Content

-Acceleration

-Ride Comfort

-Refinement

-Interior Quality

-Fuel Economy

 

 Cons:

-Price

-Rear Seat Space

-Trunk Space

 

 Overall:

Smaller and pricier than the mainstream-badged large sedans in this group, but its additional features and refinement prevent it from being an unreasonable choice.

         

  

IFCAR Home

Reviews

Pricing

Other Sources

Top Picks

Vehicle Info

About IFCAR

Contact IFCAR

© 2006, Institute For Consumer Automotive Research