|
Get
email updates from IFCAR.
Reviews of
Minivans
Impressions and critiques of
minivans. Recommended vehicles are printed in
blue in the list of models, any
model shown in bold blue
was judged to be the best vehicle in this class.
(Model names printed with the reviews will not be colored
whether a vehicle is recommended or not.)
See all Top Picks and Recommended
models by class.
|
Chevrolet Uplander

Available As: Minivan, short-length minivan
Base
Price Range (MSRP): $21,540-$29,330
Pros:
Price, interior quality, acceleration.
Cons:
Handling, interior comfort, interior
versatility, fuel economy.
Overall: With no advantages over even
like-priced competition, there is no reason to
buy an Uplander.
Rating:
4/10
Recommended: NO
|
Characteristic: |
Compared to Minivans |
Compared to All Vehicles |
|
Seat
Comfort |
3/10 |
5/10 |
|
Luxury |
4/10 |
4/10 |
|
Practicality |
4/10 |
9/10 |
|
Performance |
4/10 |
5/10 |
|
Fuel
Economy |
3/10 |
4/10 |
|
Safety |
6/10 |
7/10 |
|
Price |
7/10 |
7/10 |
|
The
Uplander fails to be competitive in the
high-standards minivan market. Unlike the competition, it
and the other "crossover sport vans" lack a third-row seat
that folds into the floor, and it doesn't offer
curtain-style side airbags. Furthermore, the Uplander
handles clumsily, has poorly shaped seats, less cargo space
than most of the competition, and mediocre gas mileage. It's
less expensive than some competitors, but it's still not the
least expensive van on the market. The Uplander's few
advantages are hardly unique in this class, and most
competitors do virtually everything better.
The Hyundai Entourage and Kia Sedona twins are very
well-rounded and very well-priced, and should be the first
thing any minivan shopper should consider. The Toyota Sienna is more
luxurious, and the Honda Odyssey
is sportier, but both are much more expensive. The Dodge Grand Caravan and Chrysler Town & Country
twins offer excellent cargo flexibility, with second and
third-row seats that can be folded into the floor, and they
are inexpensive, but they have other flaws such as a lack of
refinement, agility, interior quality, and fuel economy. And
the Nissan Quest does a
similar seat-folding trick, but is rather pricey and not as
pleasant as like-priced Honda and Toyota vans.
|
|
|
|
|
Chrysler
Town & Country

Available As: Minivan
Base
Price Range (MSRP): $22,825-$35,985
Pros:
Price, interior flexibility, interior space, ride comfort.
Cons:
Refinement and acceleration (3.3-liter),
interior quality, agility, third-row seat space.
Overall: Comfortable, practical, and
well-priced, but not without some junky feel.
Rating:
7/10
Recommended: YES
|
Characteristic: |
Compared to Minivans |
Compared to All Vehicles |
|
Seat
Comfort |
7/10 |
7/10 |
|
Luxury |
4/10 |
6/10 |
|
Practicality |
10/10 |
10/10 |
|
Performance |
4/10 |
5/10 |
|
Fuel
Economy |
6/10 |
5/10 |
|
Safety |
Unknown |
Unknown |
|
Price |
7/10 |
6/10 |
|
The Town & Country
was redesigned and improved for 2008. But while
a new available engine offers improves
acceleration and refinement, while interior
quality and ride and handling have improved, and
while a few more gadgets and seat tricks are
available, the new model continues to have most
of the strengths and weaknesses of its even
less-expensive predecessor. Its base V6, sold on
most Town & Countrys, has been with the line for
years, and is decidedly weak and noisy compared
to every other current minivan. The interior
design and quality has been upgraded, but
retains too many hard, cheap plastics and a
relatively junky feel. The suspension remains
tuned for a comfortable ride, and handling
remains somewhat sloppy. But the seats continue
to do unparalleled magic tricks; depending on
the option selected, either the second row seats
can fold flat into the floor ("Stow N Go"), or
they can be turned to face the third row with a
table installed between them ("Swivel N Go").
(You can't get both capabilities on the same
model, however.) So the Town & Country continues
to offer class-leading versatility and
resaonable comfort at competitive prices, but it
cannot match the refinement, interior quality,
and overall luxury feel of several key
competitors.
The Nissan Quest
nearly matches the Chrysler vans' Stow N Go, but its second-row seats simply drop
down, rather than folding into a storage bin to
make a completely flat cargo floor. Furthermore,
the Nissan's one-piece third row is bulkier to
raise and lower than the Chryslers' split bench,
and the van costs quite a bit more. The Hyundai Entourage
and Kia Sedona
twins are more comfortable, quieter,
better-finished and more powerful than the Town
& Country at a similar price point, though they don't match its
interior versatility. For maximum comfort and
luxury, and also commendable acceleration and
fuel economy, consider the Toyota Sienna, and for a
good blend of comfort and sportiness consider
the Honda Odyssey,
but both are rather expensive. And if you decide
on a Chrysler minivan, shop both the Town &
Country and the near-identical Dodge Grand
Caravan
for the best deal (prices are very similar).
|
|
|
|
Dodge Grand
Caravan

Available As: Minivan
Base
Price Range (MSRP): $21,930-$27,140
Pros:
Price, interior flexibility, interior space, ride comfort.
Cons:
Refinement and acceleration (3.3-liter),
interior quality, agility, third-row seat space.
Overall: Comfortable, practical, and
well-priced, but not without some junky feel.
Rating:
7/10
Recommended: YES
|
Characteristic: |
Compared to Minivans |
Compared to All Vehicles |
|
Seat
Comfort |
6/10 |
7/10 |
|
Luxury |
4/10 |
6/10 |
|
Practicality |
10/10 |
10/10 |
|
Performance |
4/10 |
5/10 |
|
Fuel
Economy |
6/10 |
5/10 |
|
Safety |
Unknown |
Unknown |
|
Price |
7/10 |
6/10 |
|
The
Grand Caravan was redesigned and improved for
2008. But while a new available engine offers
improves acceleration and refinement, while
interior quality and ride and handling have
improved, and while a few more gadgets and seat
tricks are available, the new model continues to
have most of the strengths and weaknesses of its
even less-expensive predecessor. Its base V6,
sold on most Grand Caravans, has been with the
line for years, and is decidedly weak and noisy
compared to every other current minivan. The
interior design and quality has been upgraded,
but retains too many hard, cheap plastics and a
relatively junky feel. The suspension remains
tuned for a comfortable ride, and handling
remains somewhat sloppy. But the seats continue
to do unparalleled magic tricks; depending on
the option selected, either the second row seats
can fold flat into the floor ("Stow N Go"), or
they can be turned to face the third row with a
table installed between them ("Swivel N Go").
(You can't get both capabilities on the same
model, however.) So the Grand Caravan continues
to offer class-leading versatility and
resaonable comfort at competitive prices, but it
cannot match the refinement, interior quality,
and overall luxury feel of several key
competitors.
The Nissan Quest
nearly matches the Chrysler vans' Stow N Go, but its second-row seats simply drop
down, rather than folding into a storage bin to
make a completely flat cargo floor. Furthermore,
the Nissan's one-piece third row is bulkier to
raise and lower than the Chryslers' split bench,
and the van costs quite a bit more. The Hyundai Entourage
and Kia Sedona
twins are more comfortable, quieter,
better-finished and more powerful than the Grand
Caravan at a similar price point, though they don't match its
interior versatility. For maximum comfort and
luxury, and also commendable acceleration and
fuel economy, consider the Toyota Sienna, and for a
good blend of comfort and sportiness consider
the Honda Odyssey,
but both are rather expensive. And if you decide
on a Chrysler minivan, shop both the Grand Caravan and the near-identical Chrysler Town & Country
for the best deal (prices are very similar).
|
|
|
|
Honda Odyssey

Available As: Minivan
Base
Price Range (MSRP): $25,645-$36,895
Pros:
Interior space, acceleration, handling,
safety ratings, fuel economy.
Cons:
Price.
Overall: A competent and relatively
fun-to-drive minivan that could stand to improve
its comfort and luxury for the asking price.
Rating:
8/10
Recommended: YES
|
Characteristic: |
Compared to Minivans |
Compared to All Vehicles |
|
Seat
Comfort |
8/10 |
8/10 |
|
Luxury |
7/10 |
6/10 |
|
Practicality |
8/10 |
10/10 |
|
Performance |
8/10 |
6/10 |
|
Fuel
Economy |
7/10 |
5/10 |
|
Safety |
9/10 |
9/10 |
|
Price |
4/10 |
5/10 |
|
The Odyssey is a
highly capable minivan with more focus on sport
over comfort and luxury than one would expect
from a mainstream minivan. Even consumers who
don't care if it's fast and agile can
appreciate its spacious and versatile interior,
its excellent safety ratings, and its
class-competitive fuel economy. (High-end
versions include a cylinder deactivation system
for an estimated gain of 1 mpg; some competitors
match that without added technology.) However,
the Odyssey tends to be overrated by reviewers
who place more emphasis than most minivan buyers
on the fact that it's relatively fun to drive,
in the mentality "I'd never drive a minivan, but
if I did it would be the fun one." So while the
Odyssey may be the best choice for those looking
for nimble handling in their family hauler,
others should look at the comfort and
luxury-focused competition before paying extra
for the Odyssey's driving dynamics.
The Toyota Sienna
shares most of the Odyssey's strong points, but
adds a higher-quality interior, a much smoother
and quieter ride, and even more power and better
fuel economy. But it doesn't handle as nimbly,
and isn't much less expensive. The Hyundai
Entourage and Kia Sedona twins are strong value
contenders, coming quite close to both the
Odyssey's driving dynamics and the Sienna's
luxury at a much lower price and with even
higher safety ratings. But it's not quite at
either's level, and doesn't have a very
comfortable third-row seat. The Dodge Grand Caravan
and Chrysler Town &
Country twins offer low prices
excellent cargo flexibility, with second and
third-row seats that can be folded into the
floor, but lack refinement, agility, power, and
interior quality. And the Nissan Quest nearly
matches the Chryslers' seat tricks and is much
more pleasant and luxurious, but costs much
more.
|
|
|
|
Hyundai Entourage

Available As: Minivan
Base
Price Range (MSRP): $23,795-$28,795
Pros:
Safety ratings, price, warranty, cargo
space, ride, handling, acceleration, refinement,
interior quality.
Cons:
Third-row comfort, fuel economy.
Overall: A blend of most of the best aspects
of pricier class leaders, along with
class-leading safety.
Rating:
9/10
Recommended: YES
|
Characteristic: |
Compared to Minivans |
Compared to All Vehicles |
|
Seat
Comfort |
7/10 |
7/10 |
|
Luxury |
7/10 |
6/10 |
|
Practicality |
8/10 |
10/10 |
|
Performance |
7/10 |
6/10 |
|
Fuel
Economy |
4/10 |
4/10 |
|
Safety |
10/10 |
10/10 |
|
Price |
8/10 |
6/10 |
|
The Entourage is a
value-priced minivan that meets or exceeds the
pricier established class leaders in most ways.
It is spacious and powerful, it rides and
handles well, it has excellent interior quality
and ergonomics, and did better in crash-testing
than any other minivan. The Entourage falls
between class leaders Honda Odyssey and Toyota
Sienna in offering much of the Odyssey's driving
dynamics and much of the Sienna's luxury and
refinement. A few details come up short, though,
such as the too-low third-row-seat, and the
mediocre gas mileage. But the Entourage is
clearly a top-notch minivan at bargain prices,
and deserves strong consideration from all
shoppers.
The
primary competitor to the Entourage is
its twin, the Kia Sedona. The two are
virtually identical, and typically
priced similarly, so which of the two
you choose should depend on what deal
you find at the time of your purchase.
Among other vans, consider the Honda
Odyssey for the sportiest feel of any
van, and the Toyota Sienna for the most
luxurious one. Both of those can be
quite expensive, however. For an even
lower price than the Entourage, and for
a slick system that stows second and
third-row seats into the floor, consider
the Dodge Grand Caravan, though it isn't
agile, powerful, or refined, and has a
low-quality interior and a few mediocre
crash-test scores. And for a more
refined driving experience but a similar
seat trick, consider the somewhat
expensive Nissan Quest.
|
|
|
|
Kia
Sedona

Available As: Short and regular-length
minivan
Base
Price Range (MSRP): $20,495-$26,195
Pros:
Safety ratings, price, warranty, cargo
space, ride, handling, acceleration, refinement,
interior quality.
Cons:
Third-row comfort, fuel economy.
Overall: A blend of most of the best aspects
of pricier class leaders, along with
class-leading safety.
Rating:
9/10
Recommended: YES
|
Characteristic: |
Compared to Minivans |
Compared to All Vehicles |
|
Seat
Comfort |
7/10 |
7/10 |
|
Luxury |
7/10 |
6/10 |
|
Practicality |
8/10 |
10/10 |
|
Performance |
7/10 |
6/10 |
|
Fuel
Economy |
4/10 |
4/10 |
|
Safety |
10/10 |
10/10 |
|
Price |
8/10 |
6/10 |
|
The Sedona is a
value-priced minivan that meets or exceeds the
pricier established class leaders in most ways.
It is spacious and powerful, it rides and
handles well, it has excellent interior quality
and ergonomics, and did better in crash-testing
than any other minivan. The Sedona falls
between class leaders Honda Odyssey and Toyota
Sienna in offering much of the Odyssey's driving
dynamics and much of the Sienna's luxury and
refinement. A few details come up short, though,
such as the too-low third-row-seat, and the
mediocre gas mileage. But the Sedona is
clearly a top-notch minivan at bargain prices,
and deserves strong consideration from all
shoppers.
The
primary competitor to the Sedona is
its twin, the Hyundai Entourage. The two are
virtually identical, and typically
priced similarly, so which of the two
you choose should depend on what deal
you find at the time of your purchase.
Among other vans, consider the Honda
Odyssey for the sportiest feel of any
van, and the Toyota Sienna for the most
luxurious one. Both of those can be
quite expensive, however. For an even
lower price than the Sedona, and for
a slick system that stows second and
third-row seats into the floor, consider
the Dodge Grand Caravan, though it isn't
agile, powerful, or refined, and has a
low-quality interior and a few mediocre
crash-test scores. And for a more
refined driving experience but a similar
seat trick, consider the somewhat
expensive Nissan Quest.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Last Update: 1/30/08 |
|
|
|